Disaster Readiness: Lessons From Katrina
Kathy J. Ellis
Q:
I work in a dialysis unit in the Southeastern portion of the United
States and although we were spared hurricane damage these past few
years, I would like to know about strategies that will help us prepare
for a natural disaster in the future.
A: Each
year, hurricanes threaten the Gulf but with a history of false alarms,
many residents refuse, or don’t have the means, to evacuate.
Consequently, when a hurricane strikes, heavy demands are placed on
hospitals. At Ochsner, we felt well-prepared but Katrina taught us
otherwise. We were forced to find creative ways to adapt to adverse
conditions and appreciate the broad scope of psychological issues
associated with a disaster in order to survive and reconstruct our
lives.
Following Katrina, over 4,000 displaced patients with ESRD sought care
wherever they could (Dyson, 2005). Many arrived at our emergency room
doors but due to scarce resources, were turned away if they didn’t meet
established screening criteria. Ironically, the summer heat may have
reduced admissions, thanks to the excessive sweating it induced.
Although diminished in patients with kidney disease, sweat glands will
excrete at least a marginally effective amount of excess water, urea,
ammonia, and electrolytes (Yosipovitch et al, 1994). Initially, we had
little to offer those we denied care, but later, found information on
the ESRD Network 13 website to be very helpful. We have since added
that information, as well as other modifications, to our disaster plan
as a result of lessons learned from Katrina.
First Response
Our plan includes assignment of two rotating teams who respond whenever
a warning is activated. Team A is the first responder group and Team B
relieves Team A when it is safe to return.
When
a storm threat occurs, all of our patients are dialyzed to increase
their survival odds should dialysis later become impossible. Our plan
was implemented smoothly, but following landfall of the hurricane,
opportunities for improvement or re-emphasis were identified for water,
equipment, supplies, personnel needs, evacuation preparation,
communications, visitors, and psychological impact.
Water, Equipment, and Supply Lessons
Water conservation is essential if city water is polluted and power is lost. To do that, we:
a. Reduced treatment times to 2-3 hrs,
b. Decreased dialysate flows from 800 ml/min to 500 ml/min,
c. Utilized CRRT in critical care areas on portable R.O. systems,
d. Placed machines in bypass for any treatment delays, and
e. Screened patients in the ER and only admitted
patients with critical dialysis needs (hyperkalemia, fluid overload, or
severe acidosis).
Deionization tanks may not be readily replaceable in a disaster, so
portable R.O. systems should be used exclusively and auxiliary power
assured to all equipment. Even if all equipment is in working order
prior to the storm, there will be inevitable water and hook-up
challenges, particularly if evacuation of equipment becomes necessary.
Consequently, a bio-medical technician should be part of the first
responder team.
Replacement
supplies cannot be delivered if warehouses flood or roadways become
impassable, so a 30-day stock-up should be kept during storm season.
Carts should be readily available for efficient relocation to another
area, should it become necessary.
Communications and Support Lessons
Team B’s response proved problematic since we only had their home
phone, cell phone, and pager numbers, which were useless after land
phone lines and cell towers were lost. Text messaging and satellite
phones offered alternatives, but e-mail proved to be the most
accessible and reliable for communication. Going forward, e-mail
addresses are now required for everyone. Instant messaging screen names
can also be useful if individuals need to communicate in real time, but
we do not require these.
In-house communications can also be compromised for staff members who
rely on pagers (which do not work when phone lines go down), so more
in-house phones should be allocated when an alert is activated.
Because
most Team B members evacuated with families, getting them back was
difficult since only caregivers were allowed to return to the disaster
area. Employees did not want to drive back alone (some as far as three
states away) or leave family behind without a vehicle. In the future,
Team B will stay in a regional shelter with back-up transportation. In
addition, some of the Team B staff could not get past roadblocks
without photo ID badges, so plan directives now include staff members
keeping their hosptial ID with them.
Utilizing
our visitor resources proved valuable to us and therapeutic for them.
If they wanted to help, we gave them non-clinical tasks such as making
coffee or running errands. At the end of the day, they thanked us but
we were more appreciative!
In
case the need for urgent evacuation occurs, copies of the rounding
report, medication record, and last flowsheet should be made prior to
the storm and given to each patient in a waterproof bag. As seen after
Katrina, evacuations can occur in boats so records need to be protected
and stay with patients.
Care for the Caregiver Lessons
In extreme heat, caregivers should be as familiar with symptoms of
dehydration in themselves as well as in their patients. Because lack of
mental clarity, as well as some non-specific symptoms including
headache, dizziness, nausea and vomiting, weakness, and tachycardia can
occur (Suddaith, 1991), this may be a challenge. Staff members should
drink twice as much as they thirst for.
If the city water becomes polluted or incoming water pressure is lost,
toilets may not flush and it is unsafe to brush teeth or shower. Water
from a swimming pool can be used to flush toilets, but large jugs of
pure water should be stocked for personal hygiene.
On
Day 4 after the hurricane, we realized that 3 pairs of underwear were
inadequate since washing clothes was not feasible. We now recommend 7
changes of clothes, including for off-shift hours. Other recommended
items to have include: talcum powder, dry shampoo, gum, mouthwash,
soap, towels, hand fans, batteries, large flashlight or lantern, high
calorie non-perishable food (I lost 11 pounds in 11 days, which I
coined “The Katrina Diet”), Gatorade or other drinks, transistor
radio/TV, dry ice, wet towelettes, air mattress, pump, pillow, sheets,
and lots of deodorant! A small hibachi is good to have since, without
power, the menus of cold canned food get old quick.
Diversional
activities to reduce stress cannot be underestimated. Individual items
are important, but activities others can share, such as a portable DVD
player with movies or musical instruments, are very therapeutic. Our
Medical Director, Andy Cohen, brought his guitar and our sing-along at
the end of the day made for grand memories.
Pets
were also an important consideration. In a disaster, veterinary offices
close just as other businesses and many employees simply refuse to
leave their family animals at home alone. Being sensitive to that,
Ochsner supports a volunteer pet care team who help register and
monitor pets in a safe and secure area of the parking garage lobbies.
While not ideal, it was consoling for pet owners to know their beloved
friends were safe and available for their affection on off shifts.
If
necessity is the mother of invention, then one of our dialysis nurses,
Janice Johnson, became a poster child when she devised a means for a
warm shower after we switched to icy-cold, brown well water no one
wanted to step into. Assured that the initial water crisis had abated,
she rigged some suction tubing to a spigot fed by treated water from
the holding tank in the (hot) boiler room. Our private “spa” became a
carefully guarded secret. Janice also shared the practicality of
washing underwear while wearing them to save water.
We
also learned that beauty is not even skin deep. Vanity was a wasted
effort in the heat and humidity, but losing it was also a great
equalizer. Except for the bras, we looked like throwbacks to the hippie
generation, without the nostalgia.
Psychological Stages of Disaster
By the holidays, things had deteriorated for many. Despite generous
outpourings of support to meet our basic needs, no one anticipated the
scope of psychological issues, including suicide. Consequently, when a
psychologist talked to our group on the stages of disaster (DeWolfe,
2000), we found it enlightening and reassuring. It also affirmed how
important psychological support is in every phase of a disaster, in
order to be ready for the next phase, and ultimately, to survive. The
stages of disaster are:
- Threat, warning, impact (preparation physically and psychologically; bracing),
- Heroic (rescue and recovery),
- Inventory (assessing losses; counting blessings),
- Honeymoon (relief efforts, common experience, media blitz, optimism, goodwill),
- Disillusionment (effect of delays, hassles, red tape, and other frustrations), and
- Reconstruction (new normal emerges; survivor pride)
Having
experienced each of these, it’s easy now to see we were always on a
course of renewal, but in the middle of disillusionment, the light at
the end of the tunnel was often very dim indeed.
Conclusion
More
than a year later, I believe Katrina was both the worst thing and the
best thing that ever happened to us. In a classroom of untold misery,
Katrina taught us valuable lessons that left us, in many ways, stronger
and wiser. In sharing what we learned, hopefully others will be better
prepared for whatever disasters Mother Nature may bring their way as
well.
References DeWolfe,
D.J. (2000), Training manual for mental Health and Human Service
workers in major disasters (2nd ed.) DHHS Publication No. ADM 90-538.
Washington, DC: Department of Health and Human Services.
Dyson, B. (2005). American Association of Kidney Patients disaster
relief fund to help Katrina Victims, (Press Release). Retrieved
September 13, 2005, from www.medicalnewstoday.com.
Suddarth, D.S. (Ed). (1991). The Lippincott manual of nursing practice (5th ed.) Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott Company.
Yosipovitch, G., Reis, J., Tur, E., Blau, H., Harell, D., Morduchowizc,
G. & Boner, G. (1994). Sweat electrolytes in patients with advanced
renal failure. Journal of Laboratory and Clinical Medicine, 124(6),
808-812.
| The
Clinical Consult department is designed to provide answers to questions
concerning clinical problems and to report innovative clinical
practices. Readers are invited to submit questions to be answered by a
guest consultant. Questions should provide background information and
state specific information requested. Answers will be referenced.
Manuscripts that address clinical problems or present innovative ideas
are also invited. These should be between 400 and 600 words and contain
one to three references. Address correspondence to: Charlotte Szromba,
Clinical Consult Department Editor, through the ANNA National Office;
East Holly Avenue/Box 56; Pitman NJ 08071-0056; (856) 256-2320. You may
also log onto this column at www.nephrologynursingjournal.net (click on
Department link) and email your comments to the Department Editor (see
Discussion Area). The opinions and assertions contained herein are the
private views of the contributors and do not necessarily reflect the
views of the American Nephrology Nurses’ Association. |
|